Not for profit: The role of the private sector in England’s schools
While there is a role for the private sector in our education system, schools themselves should not be run for profit. This paper argues that schools should be public institutions, situated at the heart of local communities and run in the public interest.
There is a role for the private sector in our education system. The government has introduced ‘free schools’, new independent state schools operated on a not-for-profit basis which can be established where there is parental demand. Indeed, markets in education services are likely to continue to grow as parents choose to spend more money on their children’s education.
This paper contests each of the arguments made by proponents of for-profit schools – that:
- competition between schools for pupils is the best way to increase the number of good school places and that only for-profit firms will have sufficient incentives to expand
- where for-profit providers have run schools around the world they have done so successfully
- allowing private companies to open new schools is the best way to finance the capital requirements of new school places
- schools need greater flexibility over pay and conditions to improve the quality of teaching and that allowing private providers into the system is the best way of achieving this
- the private sector already operates services in other parts of the education system, such as early years and alternative education services, so there can be no objection in principle to commercial organisations running schools.
Instead, policymakers should be focusing on doing the things that we know from international evidence do the most to raise school standards: strengthening school leadership, improving the quality of teaching, giving schools autonomy while holding them robustly to account, and systematically tackling inequalities between children from different class backgrounds.
Rick Muir, Associate Director for Public Services
In the news
Innovation and not-for-profit schools
Times Educational Supplement - 13 Aug 2012
Charities better than private providers to run schools
Third Sector - 09 Aug 2012
Author(s) : Rick Muir - 23 Aug 2012
Author(s) : Rick Muir - 07 Aug 2012
You may be interested in...
IPPR in the news
Poor pupil cash 'plugging holes in school budgets'
BBC News Website - 19 Jun 2013Labour promises ‘parent-led’ academies and stricter oversight
Financial Times - 18 Jun 2013Nick Herbert MP: The civil service reform we need
Conservativehome - 18 Jun 2013Let kids apply after their A-level results
The Independent - 18 Jun 2013
PM could appoint Whitehall high-fliers
The Herald - 18 Jun 2013Whitehall reform blueprint
Financial Times - 17 Jun 2013Biggest shake up of how Britain is governed for decades
The Independent - 17 Jun 2013
Ministers ‘must be allowed to choose officials’
The Times (£) - 17 Jun 2013Groundbreaking suggestions on civil service reform
The Guardian - 17 Jun 2013Fathers should get 'use it or lose it' parental leave
Daily Telegraph - 14 Jun 2013Foreign-born men more likely to be in work than British counterparts
The Independent - 14 Jun 2013
Labour takes aim at Murdoch with new call for media ownership cap
New Statesman - 14 Jun 2013Childcare ratio reforms
Huffington Post - 13 Jun 2013Two-year degrees floated by Welsh government
Times Higher Education - 13 Jun 2013Welfare system of ‘shared services’ after independence scorned by academics
The Times (£) - 12 Jun 2013
Immigration chaos 'won't ever be fixed'
Daily Mail - 12 Jun 2013Bring back polytechnics, argues higher education report
BBC News - 11 Jun 2013Labour promises to end Home Office "hostage" of universities
New Statesman - 11 Jun 2013Labour ‘open’ to rekindling targets for overseas student growth
Times Higher Education Supplement - 11 Jun 2013