Double Dutch: The case against deregulation and demand-led funding in childcare
Published date: 16 Oct 2012
Download full publication Purchase via print on demand
This report critically engages with the arguments and ideas put forward in childcare minister Liz Truss’ paper Affordable Quality and the deeper ideological approach that underpins them, casting doubt upon that paper's recommendations for deregulation and demand-led funding.
Despite major advances over the last 15 years, childcare in the UK is more expensive and or more variable in quality than in many other European countries. This is especially problematic given the potential of good childcare to overcome early childhood disadvantage and enable parental employment.
The argument in Liz Truss’ paper is rooted in the claim that our childcare system delivers poor value for money, for both parents and taxpayers, and she suggest that British policymakers should take inspiration from the reforms that took place in the Dutch childcare system in 2005. These reforms focused on reducing regulation, especially on childminders, and on switching to a demand-led funding model for childcare services.
This report argues that the outcomes of the Dutch reforms are not universally positive, and concludes, more generally, that this two strategic directions – deregulation and demand-led funding – are likely to take the UK's childcare system down the wrong path. Specifically, it argues that:
- reducing regulation of childminders (by loosening child-to-adult ratios or ending individual registration and inspection) would undermine quality and parental trust
- a demand-led funding system would not reduce costs or increase quality: on the contrary, it would lead to increased costs for government and parents, and to lower quality and diminished parental choice.
As an alternative source of inspiration for British policymakers, the report surveys the Danish childcare system, which:
- offers a universal national entitlement to childcare
- prioritises spending on services over spending on benefits
- fosters a high-quality workforce
- decentralises governance
- maintains relatively generous parental leave and workplace flexibility.
All this is premised on a broad political consensus and strong alliances, especially in the entrenched social partnership between employers and trade unions, and so would be difficult to import straightforwardly into the British context. However, there are a number of insights that we believe can be gained from looking elsewhere in Europe for inspiration in childcare reform.
Graeme Cooke, Research Director
In the news
Ministers make changes to childcare cost
BBC Newsnight - 11 Dec 2012
Ministers plan childcare change
BBC News Online - 11 Dec 2012
Tax relief to cut childcare cost by a third
Daily Mail - 11 Dec 2012
Why government is right to improve poverty target
Telegraph - 16 Nov 2012
Parents will be able to share mothers' leave
City AM - 13 Nov 2012
Graeme Cooke on affordable childcare (7 mins)
BBC Radio 4 Woman's Hour - 01 Nov 2012
Childcare costs outweigh benefits of working
Huffington Post - 29 Oct 2012
Childcare costs harm work spur
ITV News - 29 Oct 2012
Cost of childcare bankrupting middle Britain
Observer - 29 Oct 2012
Amber Rudd backs IPPR's Danish model for childcare
Conservativehome - 23 Oct 2012
Polly Toynbee on childcare
The Guardian - 19 Oct 2012
The real answer to better, cheaper childcare
Daily Telegraph - 17 Oct 2012
Nursery costs 27% of family income
Daily Express - 17 Oct 2012
Childcare in Denmark (33mins15s)
BBC World at One - 16 Oct 2012
Minister's past views on childcare spark row
BBC News Online - 16 Oct 2012
Denmark holds key to affordable childcare
Nursery World - 16 Oct 2012
The cost of childcare
BBC Radio 4 World at One - 15 Oct 2012
You may be interested in...
IPPR in the news
Net migration down by a third in a year
The Telegraph - 24 May 2013Dalia Ben-Galim on families (29 mins)
BBC Newsnight - 24 May 2013Minorities embrace Englishness, even as metropolitan whites shun it
The Economist - 24 May 2013Net migration to UK lowest in decade after fall in overseas students
Financial Times (£) - 24 May 2013
Number of immigrants at its lowest for a decade
Daily Mail - 24 May 2013UK’s immigration hits 10-year low
The Sun - 24 May 2013UK net migration shrinks further, official figures show
The Guardian - 24 May 2013Who benefits from welfare?
Prospect £ - 23 May 2013
UK higher education: let's not follow the leader but develop our own vision
The Guardian - 22 May 2013Mervyn King's housing warning is too little, too late
The Guardian - 21 May 2013Nigel Farage and Alex Salmond trade insults in battle of nationalists
The Guardian - 20 May 2013Local solutions are the key to full employment
New Statesman, Staggers blog - 20 May 2013
Exam fail kids are facing jobs woe
The Sun - 15 May 2013Will Ed Miliband be the Doctor Who of politics?
The Telegraph - 14 May 2013Labour will not be able to meet child poverty targets, says thinktank chief
The Guardian - 13 May 2013Slave-to-work dads ‘being squeezed out of family life,' says MP Jon Cruddas
Manchester Evening News - 13 May 2013
Laptop U: Has the future of college moved online?
The New Yorker - 13 May 2013Ed Cox on 'two-speed Britain'
Observer - 12 May 2013Francis Maude to consider fixed terms for top mandarins
Financial Times (£) - 12 May 2013Childcare reforms in chaos
Daily Mirror - 10 May 2013